Niskayuna, New York Development News

Residents Voice Strong Opposition to Birchwood Lane Sidewalk Project, Citing Cost, Need, and Environmental Concerns

During the Privilege of the Floor segment, residents expressed strong opposition to the proposed sidewalk on Birchwood Lane. Concerns included the high cost ($1 million project, 50% state/50% town funded), the low number of children walking to school in the area compared to more urban neighborhoods, the potential negative aesthetic impact on the streetscape, damage to trees, and the burden of sidewalk maintenance on elderly residents. Speakers argued that the funds could be better utilized elsewhere, suggesting a crossing guard instead. Questions were raised about the accuracy of submitted data to the state regarding reduced vehicle miles traveled and greenhouse gas emissions. The need for pedestrian safety improvements on Balltown Road near JCC/Craig was acknowledged. Additionally, a resident from Oak Tree Lane spoke against the Birchwood sidewalk, highlighting that most children walk down Oak Street and cross Birchwood, and that a crossing guard would be a better use of funds. Concerns about mailboxes, tree damage, retaining walls, and the potential for the sidewalk to become an 'ebike roadway' were also voiced. Residents sought clarification on notification processes for public hearings and expressed a desire to age in place without the added stress of sidewalk maintenance. Another resident suggested exploring alternative, narrower, or recycled material paths and questioned why the sidewalk couldn't be placed on the school side of Birchwood Lane to preserve trees and yards. The accuracy of data submitted to the state regarding vehicle miles traveled and emissions was questioned. A resident from Not Street raised issues with traffic congestion at the high school drop-off, the need for a crosswalk on Not Street near the housing development, and requested the relocation of a CDTA bus stop on Not Street due to poor conditions and lack of accessibility. Another resident discussed the potential for community internet (fiber) and concerns about speeding on Knot Street and Rosendale Road, suggesting speed cameras.